Quill and Quire

Book news

« Back to
Quillblog

How the Booker ruined James Kelman’s career

When James Kelman won the Booker prize in 1994, the Scottish novelist surely expected that Britain’s top literary award would propel him to a wider readership. But in a rare interview appearing in The Sunday Times, Kelman says the controversy surrounding his win has had a damning effect on his career:

I don’t think it [the Booker] has proved to be that good for me, he told The Sunday Times. The hostility, the attacks interfered with my work such in a way that I don’t think ever really recovered.

Perhaps some amount of controversy was inevitable: As one prurient reviewer noted at the time, Kelman’s profanity-laden How Late It Was, How Late, written in an urban Scottish argot, featured some 4,000 instances of the F-word, and one of the Booker jurors called the book “crap, quite frankly.” However, Kelman claims now that the critical controversy prevented serious consideration of his subsequent work.

Even if I do a reading just now people will say, ˜well Jim, what about your sweary words? It’s had a very sad effect; it’s not been a positive thing.

Kelman’s new novel, Keiron Smith, Boy, contains few obscenities because it is written in the voice of a child. It has earned him only £1,400 in sales, though it has won two major literary prizes and has been hailed by critics as his best novel to date.