Quill and Quire


« Back to
Book Reviews

Crimes Against My Brother

by David Adams Richards

Over his long career, David Adams Richards has carved out a unique body of work, in the process developing a form of literary expressionism that illuminates the moral depths – and depravity – of several communities along New Brunswick’s Miramichi River. Though not always explicitly Christian, Richards’ vision is framed by absolute moral values and a rejection of the liberal humanist ethos of so many contemporary authors.

What prevents his work from descending into sermonizing allegory is a seemingly folksy storytelling technique married to a gift for dialogue and detail. Like Dostoevsky, Richards reveals his characters through how they talk – to each other, to themselves, and to whatever higher power rules their troubled lives.

In Crimes Against My Brother, Richards returns to the communities near Good Friday Mountain, the setting of such recent works as The Friends of Meager Fortune and Incidents in the Life of Markus Paul, as well as his much-lauded Scotiabank Giller Prize–winning novel, Mercy Among the Children. Characters from those novels appear in minor roles in this new work, including Mercy’s saintly Sydney Henderson.

The characters alluded to in the title – Ian Preston, Evan Young, and Harold Dew – are poverty-stricken cousins who are 15 in 1974. Already doing the gruelling outdoor work of grown men, the trio makes a blood pact after nearly freezing to death on the side of Good Friday Mountain. They collectively vow to be “heroic and loyal” for the rest of their lives, and to never put their faith in “a Catholic God they did not know or believe in.”

This bond is not only a rejection of the Church, but also of the vow made by Sydney Henderson in Mercy. Sydney promised God that he would “never raise his hand or his voice to another soul,” if God allowed a boy he’d badly injured to survive. Like most of the locals, Ian, Evan, and Harold are disdainful of Sydney’s pacifist ways and the shame and poverty they cause his family.

Crimes Against My Brother is narrated by an older cousin of the boys, a local “oddity” who left the Miramichi region to attend university and went on to become a distinguished professor of sociology. He recalls the story of the pact and its tangled outcomes from the present day, reconstructing events out of his own experience, local sources, and several police investigations.

The novel traces Ian, Evan, and Harold’s transformation from recklessly proud teenagers to bitter adult enemies bent on destroying each other, either consciously in Harold and Evan’s case, or subconsciously in Ian’s. Each man is brought low by sins and passions for which he is “culpable in increments,” moral decay seeping into them via a succession of poor decisions, impulsive acts, bad luck, and rejected moments of grace and wisdom.

The principal external agent of their ruin is Lonnie Sullivan – the kind of duplicitous, morally stunted but physically vital tyrant that Richards excels at bringing to life on the page. A salvage dealer, contractor, loan shark, and land speculator, Lonnie manipulates the fortunes of dozens of families by means of bad debts, the promise of employment, and physical intimidation. He employs the three cousins as teens and soon has them deep in his debt.

Lonnie’s only rival for the boys’ loyalty is Joyce Fitzroy, their alcoholic great uncle, rumoured to have over $100,000 hidden in his shack, a sum the boys hope to inherit. Lonnie hatches a plan to pit the boys against each other – and to nab Joyce’s fortune – by playing them off each other for the affections of Annette Brideau, a beautiful teenager he has brought under his control. His machinations, always couched in the language of pragmatism and moral rectitude, eventually pay off, in ways both violent and unexpected.

Richards gradually teases out his protagonists’ betrayals of conscience and halting attempts at reform by interweaving several narrative threads that incorporate the gossip, often malicious and misinformed, of the local community. He moves from external character description to their most naked internal reflections. When Ian is out walking with Annette, whom he’s been in love with since he was 15, he realizes she has told him a lie in order to extend their time together. “It surprised Ian how some small part of him wanted it to be a lie, for that indicated something else, something new and special, between them.”

This subtle investigation into humanity’s almost infinite capacity for self-deception helps to balance the novel’s more sensational elements, which include murders, beatings, child deaths, industrial sabotage, and the swindling of the town by a multinational corporation. No conscience is left untested, but Richards also bestows tenderness and compassion on the troubled blood brothers. It makes for compelling reading.


Reviewer: James Grainger

Publisher: Doubleday Canada


Price: $32.95

Page Count: 400 pp

Format: Cloth

ISBN: 978-0-38567-116-3

Released: May

Issue Date: June 2014

Categories: Fiction: Novels