Quill and Quire

REVIEWS

« Back to
Book Reviews

The Night Garden

by Polly Horvath

Children’s literature abounds with magical gardens: from the walled plot that Mary Lennox coaxes back to life in The Secret Garden, to the setting for a time-travelling friendship in Tom’s Midnight Garden, to Oxford’s Botanic Gardens in Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials series. At once intriguing and healing, the best ones quietly become characters in their own right.

The garden in Polly Horvath’s latest middle-grade novel follows in this tradition. But the ancient night garden at East Sooke Farm – locus of a family legend involving star-crossed lovers, tragedy, and hauntings – goes one step further: it grants wishes.

The year is 1945. Twelve-year-old Franny Whitekraft has lived on the farm with her adoptive parents, Sina and Old Tom, ever since she was abandoned on their doorstep as a baby. Old Tom tends the property’s many gardens, Sina sculpts and writes letters to Prime Minister Mackenzie King – suggesting he grow facial hair to present a tougher front against Hitler and Mussolini – and Franny spends hours penning stories both fictional and true. Introverted but sparky, creative but no wimp (she takes delight in selecting the most unpleasant bird in the henhouse for Sunday supper), Franny is that rare bright heroine whose precocity never becomes irksome.

The family’s peace is shattered by the arrival of Winifred, Wilfred, and Zebediah, the children of a neighbour known as Crying Alice. Seized by a sudden need to visit her husband, Flying Bob, at the air base where he is stationed, Alice skips town, but not before convincing Sina to take the children in. The quirky siblings adapt to life on the farm with little fuss – until letters from their father start to arrive, setting off a panic that he might be about to do something that will change their lives forever.

While the war serves as a vehicle for various plot twists (just what is Flying Bob planning to do with the top-secret warplane in his charge?), its full ugliness never impinges on local events. This is, for the most part, not a war story but rather a pacy adventure that twins mystery and magic with elegant moments and beautiful descriptions: “The moonflowers open at dusk and close at dawn, their white trumpet-shaped blooms incandescent, like strings of lanterns all over the garden.”

Horvath, who’s a past winner of the Newbery Honor and a National Book Award, is at her best during reflective passages that incorporate astute social observations. Old Tom’s suspicion of invading technology will likely resonate with parents of middle-grade readers who have never known a world without social media: “It’s a slippery slope. … You don’t talk to people face-to-face anymore because the people on the radio are so much more interesting. … And then suddenly you start to think that unless you’re sitting in that chair at six o’clock every night listening to the radio, you’re missing out on something.”

If Horvath has a weakness, it’s in counterbalancing such perceptive or lyrical moments with humour that sometimes veers into the cartoonish. Occasionally, her use of whimsy risks becoming overly twee – and all the wish-granting that builds up to the madcap climax verges on ridiculous. One or two minor anachronisms break the spell – for example, there’s much talk of UFOs, a term that wasn’t coined until almost a decade later. But by the time readers reach the eloquent conclusion, which culminates in ambitious reflections on the interconnectivity and mystery of life (“What we think we want is not always what we choose. But what we choose becomes our lives”), most will be too charmed to mind.